New York (AP) — For decades, when LGBTQ people gathered to participate in New York City’s annual Pride March, they announced their presence in all the colors and types of clothing they could imagine. It was.
But soon there is something off limits: police uniforms.
As the city’s annual Pride Weekend approaches, a recent decision by the organizers of a New York City event to ban LGBTQ police officers from marching in uniform in future parades is identity and attribution, power and alienation. I put the spotlight on the problem.
For some, police should not have a unified presence in the march to commemorate the 1969 Stonewall riots caused by police raids on gay bars. Tensions between law enforcement agencies and parts of the LGBTQ community still exist half a century later.
Parade regular John Brasco said: “If you’re an officer … you could, of course, celebrate your pride, but you don’t have to wear a uniform that has perpetuated violence against many who are trying to celebrate your pride.”
For others, the presence of LGBTQ police marchers is an expression of the diversity and inclusion of fierce battles to celebrate and is a hallmark of how LGBTQ people are essential to the structure of American life.
“Why do I have to hide part of myself,” asked Ana Alboreda, a NYPD sergeant who marched several times to the parade and was vice president of the Gay Officer Action League. “Why do I have to take off my uniform shyly?”
This year is a bit controversial. Due to pandemic restrictions until recently, most of the New York City Pride events scheduled for Sunday hosted by the Heritage of Pride are virtual events.
However, the organizers said the ban would take effect next year until at least 2025.
The role that police officers should play in the annual parade has been debated for years, but has renewed heat in the national view of police atrocities.
A year ago, the streets of New York City were flooded with protests against the death of George Floyd and the clash between demonstrators and officers.
There is a long history of interaction between LGBTQ people and law enforcement agencies, especially racial minorities and transgender people, and they feel targeted and harassed by police as a system. I am.
Mark Stein, a professor of history at San Francisco State University, said the disagreement over whether uniformed police played a role in pride was “at the heart of long-standing tensions in LGBT politics.”
“Is the goal diversity, or is it the goal of dealing with the basic relationship and inequality of society?” He asked. “These are two completely different things.”
The ban is not the first of the pride march. Toronto Pride has not allowed unified police since 2017. Vancouver Pride has also begun to limit its role, but the Capital Pride Alliance began limiting it in 2018. Denver PrideFest does not allow law enforcement agencies to participate in this year’s virtual event. There is also no Capital Hill Pride Festival in Seattle, but separate from Seattle Pride.
In New York City, an alternative to the Heritage of Pride event, called the Queer Liberation March, organized as a counter-argument to what the Reclaim Pride Coalition considers to be a corporate and overly comfortable main parade, does not allow police to exist. The beginning of 2019.
Andre Thomas, co-chair of the Heritage of Pride, a group that organizes major marches in New York City, said the process leading to the ban began last year.
There were no face-to-face events in New York City Pride due to the pandemic, but Reclamation Pride marched, and finally police arrested some demonstrators and sprayed them with pepper.
That negative interaction has put pressure on the LGBTQ community to respond strongly to police abuse, and an internal conversation about the level of police guards at the NYC Pride event and how it can be done. It led to a conversation between the city and NYPD. Release the escalation.
Thomas said those discussions also included reaching out to the Gay Officer Action League. Goal members have been marching in uniform at NYC Pride since 1996 and are often cheering.
However, some members of the unsupported LGBTQ community have a much more controversial relationship with the police, Thomas said.
“We have noticed that the uniform is triggering for many in the community, which creates a feeling of being unsafe and unwelcome,” he said.
“We needed to weigh the need for a group to wear uniforms for hours and the need for people left out of society to feel safe and welcome,” he said. I did.
They spoke to GOAL, announcing the ban before Heritage did, and announcing that they had been kicked out of the parade, saying, “The decision made to appease some of the activists in our community is shameful. “.
Arboleda, GOAL’s vice president, admitted that some people had negative interactions with officers, but felt that more experienced law enforcement people outnumbered them.
“We have to think and see the big picture of what it is,” she said. A few bad experiences “do not offset millions of positive experiences.”
The ban on NYC pride for uniformed police reflects deeper tensions –
Source link The ban on NYC pride for uniformed police reflects deeper tensions –