US & World

Some abortion enemies question the new Texas ban tactical wisdom | Nationwide

The new Texas law, which bans most abortions in the state, is welcomed by many religious leaders who help strengthen the anti-abortion movement. However, some abortion opponents in the US religious community are wary of the law and question the current direction of the movement.

Vigilantism is partly related to the most novel feature of the law, which some critics consider to be an invitation to vigilantism. I earned $ 10,000 in the process.

Fordham University supports stricter national restrictions on abortion, saying the law “has serious flaws” and that anti-abortion activists are actively involved in “desperate and radical tactics.” Charles Camothy, an associate professor of theology and social ethics at Fordham University, said.

In an email, Catholic Camothy said, “Because it looks like you’re playing a legitimate game to circumvent a federal court ruling, the law has public opinion on our side for people in the pro-life. It provides the false story of not being. “

Senate Bill 8, a law, bans abortions, usually in about six weeks, when medical professionals are able to detect heart activity.It was attacked by Recent column According to Michael Sean Winters, an independent online news outlet, National Catholic Reporter and one of its senior reporters.

“I’m very afraid that the premature enforcement of this truly bizarre law turns out to be the historic beginning of a backlash against the unprepared pro-life movement,” Winters wrote. ..

He said the law’s provisions encouraged “a kind of vigilant justice that we all thought we would entrust to old Western films,” which enforced some women’s illegal and potentially dangerous abortions. He warned that he might sue.

“I hate the pro-life movement because of myopia, moral myopia, and its malice, although pro-life is as pro-life as possible,” Winters writes. “The pro-choice movement is now booming in ways that weren’t there years ago.”

In anger at SB 8, John Stow, a Catholic bishop in Lexington, Kentucky, published broader criticisms of some elements of the anti-abortion movement and their purpose, ignoring other imminent social issues. Suggested that he pursued.

“People who fight fiercely against legal abortion but are not interested in providing basic medical care to pregnant mothers and needy children, those who are not interested in refugee children, or escape from poverty People who don’t want to have a quality education don’t respect life, “Stowe tweeted.

Among stubborn supporters of Texas law, there is some contempt for abortion opponents who describe the action as a strategic mistake.

“Pro-life people who oppose the Texas SB8 play to lose. Rather, they play a controlled opposition and pay the foetation lip service, but in reality like in real life. I don’t act every day, “said Chadpek Nord. Associate Professor of Theology at The Catholic University of America.

“Whatever happens to the Texas SB8, it’s long remembered as the moment pro-life people started playing to win,” Pecknold added in an email.

Enforcement of the law has uplifted many of the top religious leaders in Texas and other states who have campaigned against abortion for years, including many of John Stow’s fellow bishops.

“We celebrate all the lives saved by this law.” Bishop’s Texas Catholic Conference, This represents 20 bishops serving the state.

“Abortion does not help women,” the bishops said. “Abortion is by no means the answer. It is always the violent loss of innocent human life.”

The statement was praised by Bishop Joseph Naumann of Kansas City, Kansas, and Chairman of the Pro Life Activities Committee of the American Catholic Bishops’ Council.

Naumann admitted that the law caused controversy, but President Joe Biden and Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi “responded with a radical pledge” to thwart the law and other severe anti-abortion measures. I criticized it.

Some prominent Southern Baptist ministers in Texas, like Naumann, welcomed the law, paying attention to aspects of its controversy.

Pastor Robert Jeffres of the First Baptist Dallas Megachurch said:

“Overall, I am very supportive and grateful for this strong affirmation of the value of life by Texas legislators,” Jeffress said in an email.

Philip Besancourt, a former senior public policy officer at the Southern Baptist Convention and now the senior pastor of Central Church at College Station, Texas, said the law was “finally good or bad”. rice field.

“But there is one community that is universally grateful for it, prenatal children whose law means life, not death,” he said in an email. “We need to see more laws in countries that are doing everything they can to save lives.”

Another Baptist minister, John Elkins, a sovereign race fellowship in Brazoria, Texas, said he welcomed the law, hoping to ban abortion altogether. He wants members of the congregation who share his perspective to find ways to help unmarried mothers in the community.

Michael New, an anti-abortionist who teaches social research at the Catholic University, called the law “unconventional” and predicted that he would face multiple legal challenges. It has already been the subject of proceedings from abortion providers and the US Department of Justice.

Nonetheless, Mr New said he was pleased that SB8 came into effect.

“People in prolife have identified strategies that have succeeded in providing legal protection to thousands of foets, at least in the short term,” he said.

Not surprisingly, SB 8 was attacked by a priest of a religious group who supported the right to abortion. Among the plaintiffs in the July proceedings against the law is Rev. Daniel Canter, senior minister of the First Unitarian Church in Dallas and former chairman of the Planned Parenthood Clergy Advocacy Commission.

The Jewish Council of Public Affairs, which represents more than 140 national and local Jewish organizations, has denounced SB 8 and other restrictions on anti-abortion as “dangerous measures” that should be thwarted by federal law.


The Associated Press’s religious coverage is supported by Lilly Endowment through The Conversation US. AP is solely responsible for this content.

Some abortion enemies question the new Texas ban tactical wisdom | Nationwide

Source link Some abortion enemies question the new Texas ban tactical wisdom | Nationwide

Related Articles

Back to top button