The Chicago Cubs 2016 World Series champion ring maker filed a federal lawsuit against auction houses and collectors on Thursday over a replica ring named after Ben Zobrist, who said the case had been stolen.
Manufacturer Jostens said the duplicate ring is worth more than $ 75,000. Jostens is seeking monetary damages determined in court.
Jostens has not returned the “stolen” sample ring that Heritage Auctions was scheduled to auction last year in a proceeding, claiming that the collector “will not release his claim to the title of the stolen sample.” ..
The proceedings, Jostens, stated that Heritage Auctions had indicated that it would not assign ownership “without a court order directing the officially executed release of the title claim or the release of the ring.”
When the auction house tweeted last June that Zobrist would be the first Cubs player ring to hit the auction block, why the most valuable players of the 2016 World Series sell his valuable possessions. Speculation was rampant, including the Cubs Clubhouse.
One player said a former Zobrist teammate could buy a ring at auction and return it to him. Heritage Auctions told The Kansas City Star that the owner of the ring was a “championship hardware collector” and bought it from Zobrist.
However, the day after the story became a hot topic in 2021. Zobrist denied he sold his ring.. His representative sent Tribune a time-stamped photo of Zobrist wearing a ring to prove that it was still his property.
“I had two conversations with him,” agent Scott Puccino told Tribune that day. “I said,’Don’t you sell it?'” He said, “No, it doesn’t make sense. Why sell this ring? I’m not going to get rid of this ring — Never, never, never. “
Heritage Auctions lawyer Josh Benesh refused to comment on the details of the proceedings or whether the ring in question was genuine. When the dispute over the title of the ring began last June, it was removed from the auction block and remained owned by Heritage.
“Heritage has a strict policy of asserting and guaranteeing that the shipper has good ownership and never knowingly sells stolen items,” Venesh said. “We also do not knowingly sell products whose authenticity is questionable.”
The auction house appears to be trapped in the middle while both the shipper and Jostines claim ownership. This question will be decided in court after both parties are unable to reach an agreement. In many cases, players can order, wear or display duplicate championship rings while keeping the real championship rings in a safe place.
According to those who saw a duplicate of the Cubs championship ring, it’s very similar to a real ring, but there are some changes that stand out when you look closely.
The revelation of Zobrist, who still had the championship ring, seemed to be the end of the story.
However, according to the proceedings, Heritage Auctions contacted Jostines on June 10, 2021 and was informed that their ring was a stolen copy. According to the proceedings, Jostine, with the permission of the Cubs, created a sample ring modeled after Zobrist and had a “characteristic feature” to distinguish it from the actual World Series ring distributed to players. rice field.
The lawsuit alleges that in February 2018, Jostens designers left seven sample rings, including the Zobrist sample, to another professional sports organization that was considering creating their own championship ring.
According to the lawsuit, the ring was stolen at some point.
“A police report was submitted, but the stolen ring was never recovered,” the proceedings said.
Jostens could determine that it was a sample ring from the Heritage Auction photo of the ring on his Twitter account. According to the proceedings, Jostens claims that he “tried to recover” stolen property “for months in collaboration with Heritage Auctions and (collectors).”
The proceedings state that the original ring was created in commemoration of “the first World Series Championship in franchise history.” However, the Cubs also won in 1907 and 2008, but no rings were awarded in these championships.
The proceedings state that Heritage Auctions has informed Jostine that it will retain ownership until “its credibility and ownership” is resolved, leading to a proceeding. According to the proceedings, Jostens is demanding “a jury trial on all jury trial claims and other jury matters.”
“We are grateful to have worked with Heritage to stop the sample ring auction,” said Chris Poitras, general manager of professional and college sports at Jostens, in a statement. “But it’s a shame that we had to take legal action to get it back. We look forward to returning this ring to Jostines.”
Jostens filed a proceeding against the auction house over Ben Zobrist’s “stolen” reproduction of the 2016 World Series ring – Reading Eagle.
Source link Jostens filed a proceeding against the auction house over Ben Zobrist’s “stolen” reproduction of the 2016 World Series ring – Reading Eagle.